Trial Excerpts
February 4, 1935
Flemington, New Jersey
Testimony of Peter Sommer for the Defense
The Court: I very much regret to be informed that there have been taken in this courtroom some movie and talking pictures of the trial that was done in defiance of the orders of the Court, and I thin it is equally well understood that it must have been done secretly and by methods that are not commonly understood ... The officers will have to be vigilant in seeing to it that these contrivances be excluded from the courtroom ...
Cross Examination (continued) by Mr. Wilentz:
Q You are a professional witness, aren't you, Mr. Sommer?
A Well, I don't qualify as a professional witness.
Q Do you not testify in court for a price?
A Why, I haven't spoken about any price.
Q Haven't you on occasions testified for money and then later when the money wasn't paid stated and admitted that you testified improperly?
A No, sir.
Q How many cases have you testified in?
A About two, I believe.
Q Tell us the cases that you testified in.
A One for the Brooklyn Railroad Company.
Q Who else did you testify for?
A I testified for the State of New Jersey in the Hall-Mills case.
Q You weren't a fingerprint expert in that case, were you?
A No, sir.
Q As a matter of fact, you never passed a civil service examination for a fingerprint expert did you?
A Yes, I did. I have the paper right here ...
[Mr. Wilentz shows the witness an affidavit, verifying that the signature was that of the witness.]
Q In what capacity did you testify for the State in the Hall-Mills case?
A As a witness for the State.
Q You were an operator for a detective agency, weren't you?
A Yes.
Q And by whom was the detective agency employed?
A They were representing the defense at the time.
Q So you worked for a detective agency representing the defense and then you testified for the State, isn't that right?
A Yes, sir.
Q Now let's see, what other cases did you testify in?
A I don't remember any other ...
Q Do you remember the case of Adeline Smith versus the Peerless Glass Company and Mink Brothers?
A And Mink Brothers, why, yes.
Q Did you testify in that case?
A Yes, I did.
Q You testified falsely in that case, didn't you?
A No, sir, I did not.
Q Now, that case involved an accident which happened in 1928, isn't that so?
A Yes, sir.
Q And you testified in that case that you had been at the stand, the scene of the accident on various occasions before 1928, did you not?
A If they put that down, I did not testify to it. If I remember rightly.
Q That was a case which involved a lawsuit in which a young lady was injured, lost an eye, I think; do you remember that?
A Yes, she lost an eye.
Q As a result of an accident at her father's stand: isn't that right?
A Yes, sir.
Q And you were called as a witness?
A Yes, with reference to what happened at the stand on various occasions prior to the accident.
Mr. Pope: I object to the question as improper cross examination.
The Court: I don't see just how it is relevant or material.
Mr. Wilentz: Well, if your Honor please, we propose to prove that this man testified falsely, knowingly, and the inquiry is for a purpose; and he testified for a price or for a promise of a price, and when it wasn't forthcoming he retracted his testimony.
The Court: I don't perceive how it is proper cross examination.
Mr. Wilentz: Well, the witness testified he does not testify for a price.
The Court: You may ask him whether or not he testified for a price in that particular case.
Q Did you not testify in the case of Adeline Smith versus The Peerless Glass Company and Mink Brothers in 1930, because you were promised money?
A They told me they would pay my expenses.
Q You did not know anything about the accident?
A Not the accident, no, sir.
Q And you knew nothing about that place prior to the accident, did you?
A No, sir.
Q But you did testify in court to the contrary, didn't you, that you did know?
A Of the conditions that went on there.
Q You testified to conditions that went on there prior to the accident?
A I didn't state that. In fact, I had a row with the lawyers when I went into court.
Q All right, do you remember in this affidavit you said, referring to some lawyer: "He then discussed with me"-
[Defense objects, Court allows the State to pursue the issue of false testimony, not the reimbursement.]
Q Didn't you then make an affidavit, after you had given your testimony, that you had testified falsely?
A I made an affidavit that the lawyer wanted me to testify to certain things which I didn't see.
Q Had you ever been to the Smith stand before 1928?
A That I don't remember.
Q Well, you swore in this affidavit that you hadn't been, isn't that a fact? Will you say now that you did not testify falsely in this Smith case?
A Not to my knowledge. In fact, as I stated when I walked in there, the lawyer came to me, he had an artificial arm and he took me aside and he wanted for me to say certain things, which I absolutely refused, and he says, "You might as well go home." I says, "I can go home right now."
Q Did you go home?
A Why, no, I didn't go.
Q And you testified about a matter of which you knew absolutely nothing, isn't that right?
A I testified about certain bottles that exploded there, which I did witness.
Q That's so, but the date you made a mistake in, didn't you?
A If there was a mistake, it wasn't deliberately done.
Q No, but you found out later you made a mistake as to the date?
A I think my attention was called to it, yes.
Q And you found out that you made an error about the date. So that when you were on the stand in 1930 you testified that you saw these bottles explode before 1928, and then later you found out that when you saw them explode it was after 1928, isn't that right.
A That was after she had the accident.
Q It was after she had the accident that you saw the bottles explode, but in your testimony you made the mistake of testifying that you saw the bottles explode before the accident, isn't that right?
A Not to my knowledge.
Q You don't ever remember being to Smith's stand before 1928, do you?
A I can't say positively yes or no.
Q Well, you wouldn't swear that you had been, would you?
A No, I would not.
Q Let me read you the question and the answer then.
[Mr. Pope objects. Mr. Wilentz wants to pursue the matter further. The Court is wary of introducing separate cases into this one, requiring new witnesses. The State proceeds on admonition that it will be bound by the witnesses answer under cross examination.]
Q So that at trial you testified to the explosion of bottles before 1928 and then later learned that you had been mistaken?
A That was an error made, which I went and had corrected later on.
Q And you went and had it corrected with the affidavit?
A Yes.
Q Isn't it a fact that you only had it corrected because you weren't paid the money? That you threatened to go to the District Attorney, and when he paid you $15 you didn't go to the D.A.?
A That was my expenses
Mr. Wilentz: Yes. That is all.
Re-Direct by Mr. Reilly:
Q Were you called as a witness to demonstrate the theory of law that like accidents had occurred at this stand prior to the date that the girl was injured?
A I really don't know.
Q Had you seen bottles explode at the stand before the trial?
A Yes, before the trial.
Q Now, whether you gave testimony in that action or not, there isn't any doubt but what you were on this ferry boat, is there?
A I was on the ferry boat, yes, sir.
Q Is it a fact that you reported the next day to the police?
A It is.
Q And you didn't anticipate that you would ever testify in any trial of Hauptmann, who wasn't under arrest then?
A No, sir.
[Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Wilentz; followed by a Re-Direct, by a Re-Cross, by a Re-Direct. No new information is presented, just more jousting.]
Cross Examination (continued) by Mr. Wilentz:
Q You are a professional witness, aren't you, Mr. Sommer?
A Well, I don't qualify as a professional witness.
Q Do you not testify in court for a price?
A Why, I haven't spoken about any price.
Q Haven't you on occasions testified for money and then later when the money wasn't paid stated and admitted that you testified improperly?
A No, sir.
Q How many cases have you testified in?
A About two, I believe.
Q Tell us the cases that you testified in.
A One for the Brooklyn Railroad Company.
Q Who else did you testify for?
A I testified for the State of New Jersey in the Hall-Mills case.
Q You weren't a fingerprint expert in that case, were you?
A No, sir.
Q As a matter of fact, you never passed a civil service examination for a fingerprint expert did you?
A Yes, I did. I have the paper right here ...
[Mr. Wilentz shows the witness an affidavit, verifying that the signature was that of the witness.]
Q In what capacity did you testify for the State in the Hall-Mills case?
A As a witness for the State.
Q You were an operator for a detective agency, weren't you?
A Yes.
Q And by whom was the detective agency employed?
A They were representing the defense at the time.
Q So you worked for a detective agency representing the defense and then you testified for the State, isn't that right?
A Yes, sir.
Q Now let's see, what other cases did you testify in?
A I don't remember any other ...
Q Do you remember the case of Adeline Smith versus the Peerless Glass Company and Mink Brothers?
A And Mink Brothers, why, yes.
Q Did you testify in that case?
A Yes, I did.
Q You testified falsely in that case, didn't you?
A No, sir, I did not.
Q Now, that case involved an accident which happened in 1928, isn't that so?
A Yes, sir.
Q And you testified in that case that you had been at the stand, the scene of the accident on various occasions before 1928, did you not?
A If they put that down, I did not testify to it. If I remember rightly.
Q That was a case which involved a lawsuit in which a young lady was injured, lost an eye, I think; do you remember that?
A Yes, she lost an eye.
Q As a result of an accident at her father's stand: isn't that right?
A Yes, sir.
Q And you were called as a witness?
A Yes, with reference to what happened at the stand on various occasions prior to the accident.
Mr. Pope: I object to the question as improper cross examination.
The Court: I don't see just how it is relevant or material.
Mr. Wilentz: Well, if your Honor please, we propose to prove that this man testified falsely, knowingly, and the inquiry is for a purpose; and he testified for a price or for a promise of a price, and when it wasn't forthcoming he retracted his testimony.
The Court: I don't perceive how it is proper cross examination.
Mr. Wilentz: Well, the witness testified he does not testify for a price.
The Court: You may ask him whether or not he testified for a price in that particular case.
Q Did you not testify in the case of Adeline Smith versus The Peerless Glass Company and Mink Brothers in 1930, because you were promised money?
A They told me they would pay my expenses.
Q You did not know anything about the accident?
A Not the accident, no, sir.
Q And you knew nothing about that place prior to the accident, did you?
A No, sir.
Q But you did testify in court to the contrary, didn't you, that you did know?
A Of the conditions that went on there.
Q You testified to conditions that went on there prior to the accident?
A I didn't state that. In fact, I had a row with the lawyers when I went into court.
Q All right, do you remember in this affidavit you said, referring to some lawyer: "He then discussed with me"-
[Defense objects, Court allows the State to pursue the issue of false testimony, not the reimbursement.]
Q Didn't you then make an affidavit, after you had given your testimony, that you had testified falsely?
A I made an affidavit that the lawyer wanted me to testify to certain things which I didn't see.
Q Had you ever been to the Smith stand before 1928?
A That I don't remember.
Q Well, you swore in this affidavit that you hadn't been, isn't that a fact? Will you say now that you did not testify falsely in this Smith case?
A Not to my knowledge. In fact, as I stated when I walked in there, the lawyer came to me, he had an artificial arm and he took me aside and he wanted for me to say certain things, which I absolutely refused, and he says, "You might as well go home." I says, "I can go home right now."
Q Did you go home?
A Why, no, I didn't go.
Q And you testified about a matter of which you knew absolutely nothing, isn't that right?
A I testified about certain bottles that exploded there, which I did witness.
Q That's so, but the date you made a mistake in, didn't you?
A If there was a mistake, it wasn't deliberately done.
Q No, but you found out later you made a mistake as to the date?
A I think my attention was called to it, yes.
Q And you found out that you made an error about the date. So that when you were on the stand in 1930 you testified that you saw these bottles explode before 1928, and then later you found out that when you saw them explode it was after 1928, isn't that right.
A That was after she had the accident.
Q It was after she had the accident that you saw the bottles explode, but in your testimony you made the mistake of testifying that you saw the bottles explode before the accident, isn't that right?
A Not to my knowledge.
Q You don't ever remember being to Smith's stand before 1928, do you?
A I can't say positively yes or no.
Q Well, you wouldn't swear that you had been, would you?
A No, I would not.
Q Let me read you the question and the answer then.
[Mr. Pope objects. Mr. Wilentz wants to pursue the matter further. The Court is wary of introducing separate cases into this one, requiring new witnesses. The State proceeds on admonition that it will be bound by the witnesses answer under cross examination.]
Q So that at trial you testified to the explosion of bottles before 1928 and then later learned that you had been mistaken?
A That was an error made, which I went and had corrected later on.
Q And you went and had it corrected with the affidavit?
A Yes.
Q Isn't it a fact that you only had it corrected because you weren't paid the money? That you threatened to go to the District Attorney, and when he paid you $15 you didn't go to the D.A.?
A That was my expenses
Mr. Wilentz: Yes. That is all.
Re-Direct by Mr. Reilly:
Q Were you called as a witness to demonstrate the theory of law that like accidents had occurred at this stand prior to the date that the girl was injured?
A I really don't know.
Q Had you seen bottles explode at the stand before the trial?
A Yes, before the trial.
Q Now, whether you gave testimony in that action or not, there isn't any doubt but what you were on this ferry boat, is there?
A I was on the ferry boat, yes, sir.
Q Is it a fact that you reported the next day to the police?
A It is.
Q And you didn't anticipate that you would ever testify in any trial of Hauptmann, who wasn't under arrest then?
A No, sir.
[Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Wilentz; followed by a Re-Direct, by a Re-Cross, by a Re-Direct. No new information is presented, just more jousting.]