Trial Excerpts
February 1, 1935
Flemington, New Jersey
Testimony of John Trendley for the Defense
Direct examination continued by Mr. Reilly:
Q Mr. Trendley, did you see the ransom notes?
A I did.
Q Have you been examining the photographic copies offered in evidence by the State?
A I have.
Q And Mr. Osborn's charts? And all of the evidence introduced from the handwriting experts the Hauptmann writing and the notes?
A I have.
Q As a result of your study, are you in a position to render an opinion as to whether or not Hauptmann wrote the ransom notes?
A In my opinion he did not.
Q Now, I am going to take the charts of the first witness, Osborn. Each [of the State's experts] does not use the same letter or words upon which he bases his opinion, is that correct?
A Yes.
Q By that I mean did each and every expert called by the State use the same identical chart for his testimony as was used by Mr. Osborn?
A No, sir.
[Mr. Reilly compares the nursery note, exhibit 18, with Osborn's charts, pointing out with the assistance of the witness, the words not on the State's charts, beginning with the salutation: "Dear Sir!" Mr. Reilly proceeds letter-by-letter, character-by-character, finally coming to a "y"; Osborn's charts had "y"s in a few places, one of which is the Hauptmann request writing.]
Q Looking at the "y" of the ransom note, do you find any "y" that corresponds with any "y" Mr. Osborn had in his column ransom notes?
A I do not.
Q With any of the "y"s in the Hauptmann request writing?'
A Let me see. I do not.
Q Now, in your examination, did you examine the handwriting of any other people?
A I did.
Q Did you examine the handwriting of Isidor Fisch?
A I did.
Q Am I correct in asking you this question: That the first line, "Dear Sir!" and the second line "Have 50,000$ ready, 25,000$ in" -- the first two lines of the nursery note -- there is no word, letter or symbol indicated upon the Osborn chart?
A There is not.
[Letters in additional lines of the nursery note are taken, sequentially, with the witness looking for samples in Osborn's charts, but not finding any present.]
Q Is it possible, Mr. Trendley, to change the pattern of any handwriting by the use of a retouching pencil or the etching knife on the negative?
A No, it isn't.
Q Is it possible to distort the handwriting by photography?
A Oh, yes; you can do a lot of that stuff with photography
Q We find here, on S-112, a ransom note, a "y" that ends with a straight downward stroke, and then another one along side of it with a downward stroke and a hook on the right?
A Yes.
Q And then we find in the Hauptmann request writings a "y" on the same chart, downward stroke, hooked to the left, correct?
A We do.
[A protracted comparison of "y"s follows: initial strokes, up slopes, the belly, ]
Q So then is it not a fact that beginning with line 1 of the ransom note, through line 2, line 3 line 4 to the end of line 5, you cannot find on Mr. Osborn's chart any symbol, letter or word taken from those five lines?
A I cannot.
Q It is a fact, is it not, that these are photographic reproductions according to Mr. Osborn's testimony?
A Yes, I heard him.
Q And did you hear him testify that one of the notes he examined was the nursery note which I hold in my hand?
A Yes, sir.
[More discussion about slants, shading, pressure on the various up or down swings.]
Q Does that bear out your opinion that this entire note was written by a left handed man who was trying to disguise his handwriting?
A Yes, sir.
[More discourse about unique formation of letters, German handwriting ]
Q Is it significant?
A It is.
Q Is it unusual?
A It is.
Q Is it such a distinctive character that a man of twenty year's experience or any expert of five or ten or fifteen years should have devoted attention to those characters?
A Certainly would.
Q Do you find it in the Osborn chart?
A I do not.
Q Then am I correct in saying that in the first ten lines of the nursery note the only symbol or word out of the ten lines photographed by Mr. Osborn from which he makes his comparison and his opinion is the word i-s.
A I-s is the only word.
Q Is it not a fact in this ransom note left in the crib that one part is straight up and down and the rest, another part, rather, is to the left, another part to the right, there is a continual variance in the writing and printing?
A All throughout.
Q So taking the whole ransom note from top to bottom, we find that Mr. Osborn, testifying for over forty years all over the country, with samples of the defendant's handwriting before him, and with this note, the first found in the nursery, as a comparative test upon which he makes his observations and opinion to this jury, picks out the word i-s "is," and compares it with i-s's of Hauptmann's is that correct?
A It is.
Q Picks out the word "singnature" and compares it with nothing on the chart from Hauptmann's writing?
A That is correct.
Q In your opinion would that be sufficient to send a man to the electric chair?
Mr. Lanigan: That is objected to.
The Court: The objection is sustained.
Mr. Lanigan: I ask the Court to instruct the jury to disregard counsel's remark.
The Court: I didn't hear the remark.
Q Now, Mr. Trendley, you have given a great deal of thought to this case, haven't you?
A I should say I have.
Q In fact you volunteered your services in this case, didn't you?
A I did.
Q From St. Louis, is that right?
A Yes, sir.
Q I want to call your attention to some other letters and then I am through with you. You have indicated to me that you would like to speak about some comparisons? In the "a"s?
A Yes. In examining the ransom notes, I think there were something like over three hundred a's and I find al through the a's it is a round form or what you call a square form "a", entirely. In all of the request writings I find, and the other writings, I find the a's of the oval form, in which the height exceeded the width. Now my contention would be that no man -- it would be humanly impossible, no matter how skillful a writer you were, to write fourteen letters at fourteen different intervals without injecting some of your characteristics. It's an unconscious movement, a nervous reflex, and is independent of the writer's own will, and I would expect to find over half of his characteristics in those ransom notes if Hauptmann ever penned a line in it.
[A similar analysis was addressed to "k's", 39 present, none of which leaned as did Hauptmann's, to the right.]
A I never found a "K" of Hauptmann's style of writing, he never deviated from his own handwriting [in the request writings]. I think that is the most outstanding characteristic in this whole case of the ransom letters, that a man two years after -- if Hauptmann wrote those letters, he would have to disguise all his letters and he couldn't carry 26 letters [the "K's"] in his mind while he was writing.
[Next letter is "X", especially as written by Germanic peoples prior to the War.]
Q You have seen many specimens of x's have you not?
A Well, I first heard of this case on September the 24th and I was in Springfield, Illinois. I was examining the Communistic ticket for the State Election and they were --
Mr. Lanigan: That is objected to. [Sustained.]
Q Now you also heard Mr. Osborn say that in all his experiences it struck him as unusual and a personal characteristic unto the defendant alone that there was a hyphen between New and York.
A I was surprised.
Q You heard him say it?
A Yes, all eight of them.
Q And how many envelopes and letters have you examined since Mr. Osborn made that startling declaration, from all parts of the world and every one had a hyphen between New and York?
A I guess a hundred and something.
Q And is it not a characteristic of the foreigner to always put in his hyphen?
A Certainly.
Q Even in the word "Pittsburgh," do they not put in a hyphen?
A Yes, sir.
Mr. Reilly: You may take the witness.
Cross Examination by Mr. Lanigan:
Q Mr. Trendley, you offered your services in this case prior to the time you had examined the documents, didn't you?
A Yes, sir. I had seen some copies of the signatures and writing in the Springfield Record. I saw some things that were very indicative to me that Hauptmann did not write these letters.
Q Now, Mr. Trendley, when you testify for a witness, you frequently prepare charts and photographs do you not?
A Sometimes, if it is a big case.
Q Yet in a case like this you prepared no charts, did you?
A How could we when you wouldn't surrender nothing.
Q Who?
A You. You didn't even want to let me look at the original.
Q When was that?
A When I was down at Trenton for two days and got two hours on them.
Q So your opinion is based on your two and a half hour examination of the original documents?
A That, coupled with day and night with these books [of photographs of the documents].
Q [What] about misspellings? The "h-t-e". The fact that it appears three times in the Hauptmann writings and the same misspelling, h-t-e, appears in the ransom notes, has no significance to you?
A Not when I understood how this Hauptmann writing was made.
Q How do you understand it was made?
A It was made under the police. All the dictated letters were taken in a police station. I wouldn't take anything written in a police station.
Q Why not?
A That is in regard to misspelled words. You would spell what they tell you to spell
Q [Concerning the "x"s again] Well, here it is again in the word "expenses", isn't it?
A Yes. That is different than the others. The pen pressure there; there is an impulse made -- that has been written over; that's one of the patched lines, this is. We examined that under the microscope, and that's patched. That was made this way and corrected. That has been worked over.
Q Now, have you examined any other charts presented in this case except the Osborn charts?
A Yes. I think all the others, Tyrrell, Clark Sellers. The result was that I found a great many of them had pretty nearly all the same words, and I just used Osborn's from then on.
Q Now, I understood you to testify that the first note, the crib note, had been written with the left hand?
A Yes.
Q How did you determine that?
A Well, I practiced myself.
Q Show me how you practiced.
A I found in writing that I had great trouble, I couldn't use my wrist, because my whole weight was laying on my wrist.
[Mr. Trendley demonstrates on a pad, writing "have" with each hand.]
Q Now if a person wrote the crib note with his left hand and wrote the subsequent notes with his right hand, they naturally would be different, wouldn't they?
A He wrote the first four lines of the second note with his left hand. Then he turned to his right hand.
Q So that the difference in the use of the hands would account for the dissimilarity?
A Oh, it is very striking.
Mr. Lanigan: That is all.
Q Mr. Trendley, did you see the ransom notes?
A I did.
Q Have you been examining the photographic copies offered in evidence by the State?
A I have.
Q And Mr. Osborn's charts? And all of the evidence introduced from the handwriting experts the Hauptmann writing and the notes?
A I have.
Q As a result of your study, are you in a position to render an opinion as to whether or not Hauptmann wrote the ransom notes?
A In my opinion he did not.
Q Now, I am going to take the charts of the first witness, Osborn. Each [of the State's experts] does not use the same letter or words upon which he bases his opinion, is that correct?
A Yes.
Q By that I mean did each and every expert called by the State use the same identical chart for his testimony as was used by Mr. Osborn?
A No, sir.
[Mr. Reilly compares the nursery note, exhibit 18, with Osborn's charts, pointing out with the assistance of the witness, the words not on the State's charts, beginning with the salutation: "Dear Sir!" Mr. Reilly proceeds letter-by-letter, character-by-character, finally coming to a "y"; Osborn's charts had "y"s in a few places, one of which is the Hauptmann request writing.]
Q Looking at the "y" of the ransom note, do you find any "y" that corresponds with any "y" Mr. Osborn had in his column ransom notes?
A I do not.
Q With any of the "y"s in the Hauptmann request writing?'
A Let me see. I do not.
Q Now, in your examination, did you examine the handwriting of any other people?
A I did.
Q Did you examine the handwriting of Isidor Fisch?
A I did.
Q Am I correct in asking you this question: That the first line, "Dear Sir!" and the second line "Have 50,000$ ready, 25,000$ in" -- the first two lines of the nursery note -- there is no word, letter or symbol indicated upon the Osborn chart?
A There is not.
[Letters in additional lines of the nursery note are taken, sequentially, with the witness looking for samples in Osborn's charts, but not finding any present.]
Q Is it possible, Mr. Trendley, to change the pattern of any handwriting by the use of a retouching pencil or the etching knife on the negative?
A No, it isn't.
Q Is it possible to distort the handwriting by photography?
A Oh, yes; you can do a lot of that stuff with photography
Q We find here, on S-112, a ransom note, a "y" that ends with a straight downward stroke, and then another one along side of it with a downward stroke and a hook on the right?
A Yes.
Q And then we find in the Hauptmann request writings a "y" on the same chart, downward stroke, hooked to the left, correct?
A We do.
[A protracted comparison of "y"s follows: initial strokes, up slopes, the belly, ]
Q So then is it not a fact that beginning with line 1 of the ransom note, through line 2, line 3 line 4 to the end of line 5, you cannot find on Mr. Osborn's chart any symbol, letter or word taken from those five lines?
A I cannot.
Q It is a fact, is it not, that these are photographic reproductions according to Mr. Osborn's testimony?
A Yes, I heard him.
Q And did you hear him testify that one of the notes he examined was the nursery note which I hold in my hand?
A Yes, sir.
[More discussion about slants, shading, pressure on the various up or down swings.]
Q Does that bear out your opinion that this entire note was written by a left handed man who was trying to disguise his handwriting?
A Yes, sir.
[More discourse about unique formation of letters, German handwriting ]
Q Is it significant?
A It is.
Q Is it unusual?
A It is.
Q Is it such a distinctive character that a man of twenty year's experience or any expert of five or ten or fifteen years should have devoted attention to those characters?
A Certainly would.
Q Do you find it in the Osborn chart?
A I do not.
Q Then am I correct in saying that in the first ten lines of the nursery note the only symbol or word out of the ten lines photographed by Mr. Osborn from which he makes his comparison and his opinion is the word i-s.
A I-s is the only word.
Q Is it not a fact in this ransom note left in the crib that one part is straight up and down and the rest, another part, rather, is to the left, another part to the right, there is a continual variance in the writing and printing?
A All throughout.
Q So taking the whole ransom note from top to bottom, we find that Mr. Osborn, testifying for over forty years all over the country, with samples of the defendant's handwriting before him, and with this note, the first found in the nursery, as a comparative test upon which he makes his observations and opinion to this jury, picks out the word i-s "is," and compares it with i-s's of Hauptmann's is that correct?
A It is.
Q Picks out the word "singnature" and compares it with nothing on the chart from Hauptmann's writing?
A That is correct.
Q In your opinion would that be sufficient to send a man to the electric chair?
Mr. Lanigan: That is objected to.
The Court: The objection is sustained.
Mr. Lanigan: I ask the Court to instruct the jury to disregard counsel's remark.
The Court: I didn't hear the remark.
Q Now, Mr. Trendley, you have given a great deal of thought to this case, haven't you?
A I should say I have.
Q In fact you volunteered your services in this case, didn't you?
A I did.
Q From St. Louis, is that right?
A Yes, sir.
Q I want to call your attention to some other letters and then I am through with you. You have indicated to me that you would like to speak about some comparisons? In the "a"s?
A Yes. In examining the ransom notes, I think there were something like over three hundred a's and I find al through the a's it is a round form or what you call a square form "a", entirely. In all of the request writings I find, and the other writings, I find the a's of the oval form, in which the height exceeded the width. Now my contention would be that no man -- it would be humanly impossible, no matter how skillful a writer you were, to write fourteen letters at fourteen different intervals without injecting some of your characteristics. It's an unconscious movement, a nervous reflex, and is independent of the writer's own will, and I would expect to find over half of his characteristics in those ransom notes if Hauptmann ever penned a line in it.
[A similar analysis was addressed to "k's", 39 present, none of which leaned as did Hauptmann's, to the right.]
A I never found a "K" of Hauptmann's style of writing, he never deviated from his own handwriting [in the request writings]. I think that is the most outstanding characteristic in this whole case of the ransom letters, that a man two years after -- if Hauptmann wrote those letters, he would have to disguise all his letters and he couldn't carry 26 letters [the "K's"] in his mind while he was writing.
[Next letter is "X", especially as written by Germanic peoples prior to the War.]
Q You have seen many specimens of x's have you not?
A Well, I first heard of this case on September the 24th and I was in Springfield, Illinois. I was examining the Communistic ticket for the State Election and they were --
Mr. Lanigan: That is objected to. [Sustained.]
Q Now you also heard Mr. Osborn say that in all his experiences it struck him as unusual and a personal characteristic unto the defendant alone that there was a hyphen between New and York.
A I was surprised.
Q You heard him say it?
A Yes, all eight of them.
Q And how many envelopes and letters have you examined since Mr. Osborn made that startling declaration, from all parts of the world and every one had a hyphen between New and York?
A I guess a hundred and something.
Q And is it not a characteristic of the foreigner to always put in his hyphen?
A Certainly.
Q Even in the word "Pittsburgh," do they not put in a hyphen?
A Yes, sir.
Mr. Reilly: You may take the witness.
Cross Examination by Mr. Lanigan:
Q Mr. Trendley, you offered your services in this case prior to the time you had examined the documents, didn't you?
A Yes, sir. I had seen some copies of the signatures and writing in the Springfield Record. I saw some things that were very indicative to me that Hauptmann did not write these letters.
Q Now, Mr. Trendley, when you testify for a witness, you frequently prepare charts and photographs do you not?
A Sometimes, if it is a big case.
Q Yet in a case like this you prepared no charts, did you?
A How could we when you wouldn't surrender nothing.
Q Who?
A You. You didn't even want to let me look at the original.
Q When was that?
A When I was down at Trenton for two days and got two hours on them.
Q So your opinion is based on your two and a half hour examination of the original documents?
A That, coupled with day and night with these books [of photographs of the documents].
Q [What] about misspellings? The "h-t-e". The fact that it appears three times in the Hauptmann writings and the same misspelling, h-t-e, appears in the ransom notes, has no significance to you?
A Not when I understood how this Hauptmann writing was made.
Q How do you understand it was made?
A It was made under the police. All the dictated letters were taken in a police station. I wouldn't take anything written in a police station.
Q Why not?
A That is in regard to misspelled words. You would spell what they tell you to spell
Q [Concerning the "x"s again] Well, here it is again in the word "expenses", isn't it?
A Yes. That is different than the others. The pen pressure there; there is an impulse made -- that has been written over; that's one of the patched lines, this is. We examined that under the microscope, and that's patched. That was made this way and corrected. That has been worked over.
Q Now, have you examined any other charts presented in this case except the Osborn charts?
A Yes. I think all the others, Tyrrell, Clark Sellers. The result was that I found a great many of them had pretty nearly all the same words, and I just used Osborn's from then on.
Q Now, I understood you to testify that the first note, the crib note, had been written with the left hand?
A Yes.
Q How did you determine that?
A Well, I practiced myself.
Q Show me how you practiced.
A I found in writing that I had great trouble, I couldn't use my wrist, because my whole weight was laying on my wrist.
[Mr. Trendley demonstrates on a pad, writing "have" with each hand.]
Q Now if a person wrote the crib note with his left hand and wrote the subsequent notes with his right hand, they naturally would be different, wouldn't they?
A He wrote the first four lines of the second note with his left hand. Then he turned to his right hand.
Q So that the difference in the use of the hands would account for the dissimilarity?
A Oh, it is very striking.
Mr. Lanigan: That is all.