Trial Excerpts
February 1, 1935
Flemington, New Jersey
Testimony of Peter Sommer for the Defense
PETER SOMMER, sworn as a witness in behalf of the defendant:
Direct Examination by Mr. Reilly:
Q Mr. Sommer, what is your business?
A Why, my profession is a fingerprint expert.
Q Connected with whom?
A I was with the City in that capacity, but not now.
Q What do you do now for a living?
A I am with the Building & Supply Division of the Department of Public Welfare, City of New York.
Q On the evening of March 1st, 1932, where were you, in the early evening?
A In the early evening I was in Fairview, New Jersey.
Q Were you visiting there?
A Why, no, I was over there giving a fingerprinting instruction to William Ackerman, a policeman.
Q How did you travel, by car?
A No, by trolley car. I came down to the 42nd street ferry, Weehawken.
Q And what time did you arrive at the ferry?
A It was between 12 and 12:20.
Q Did you notice any people from the trolley that were afterwards on the ferry boat with you?
A There was two men.
Q Did you get a good look at them?
A A fairly good look at them, yes sir.
Q I show you a picture and ask you is that the man you saw on the trolley car?
A No, but I saw this man on the ferryboat.
Q And how near were you to him on the ferry?
A Why, I sat across the way from him.
Q How long were you riding on the ferryboat with this man under observation?
A Why, from the Jersey side to the New York side, about eight or ten minutes.
Q When the ferryboat landed, what did you see the man whose picture you identified here do?
A Why, him and another man assisted a lady on the trolley, with a baby; the woman had a baby.
Q And did you get on that trolley car?
A I did.
Q Did you get a good look at the woman holding the baby?
A What drew my attention to the woman, she was very nervous.
Q Did you get a good look at her?
A I did.
Q I show you Defendant's Exhibit 7 and ask if you recognize the woman in the trolley car with the baby?
A I would say that resembles the woman very strongly.
Q How was she dressed?
A She had a brown coat on with brown fur cuffs, and a brown collar. The coat was open. She had sort of a low cut waist and she had a sort of pearl necklace around her.
Q Now describe her actions in the trolley car with the baby.
A From the time she got on she appeared nervous, she always had one foot -- (witness indicates by holding his arms out) and as the car slowed up or stopped, she just appeared as though she was ready to jump out.
Q How was she holding the baby, what was the baby wrapped in?
A The baby was wrapped in a blanket. She would lift the baby up and the blanket slipped and I noticed the baby was dressed in a one-piece nighty.
Q And was the baby a brunette or a blond?
A The baby was a blond.
Q And how old?
A I would say about two years old.
Q When did you first learn of the kidnapping of the Lindbergh baby?
A Ten forty-five the next morning, I heard it over the radio.
Q Did you report the incident that you had seen the night before to the police?
A I did. On March 2nd, to Detective Mulaney of the 81st Precinct.
Q Did you report it to anyone else?
A I wrote a letter to the State Police, Trenton, New Jersey stating my experience on the ferry.
Q Did you ever get an answer?
A I did not. Nobody ever came to investigate.
Q How did you come to be a witness in this case?
A I wrote you a letter, about two weeks ago.
Q Before that you didn't even know me?
A I am not interested in you.
Q You are here in the interests of justice?
A I am.
Mr. Reilly: You may inquire.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Wilentz:
Q Did you communicate with the police after you spoke to this detective in New York on March 2nd, or was that the only incident?
A When I reported there they told me they had hundreds of clues.
Q That is right. Didn't they tell you that they had hundreds of people that came in and said they saw men with babies all over the country that night?
A Yes.
Q So they didn't put much stock in the story?
A Why, I don't know.
Q Well, they never came back, did they?
A That I can't say, because I moved after that.
Q Now, the short man you saw on the ferry, you didn't see on the trolley car, correct?
A Positive, that is correct.
Q Now the tall man that you say helped the woman on the trolley car, did you see him on the trolley car?
A He was on the trolley car.
[Mr. Wilentz pursues the witness' identification and travels, trying better to define where the tall and short men were at various times, going unsatisfactorily in circles.]
Mr. Reilly: I object to that. There is no contradiction. The witness has testified he came down on the Jersey side on a trolley car. He crossed over on a ferryboat and got on another trolley car in New York.
The Court: I will allow the question.
[More confusing dialogue between Mr. Wilentz and the witness concerning where and when Mr. Sommer encountered the two men.]
Q Now, am I mixing you up again?
A Why, positively, I want it explained and you told me to answer the question. I am trying to tell you when we got on the ferry the tall man got on the boat and I didn't see, I couldn't swear that the other short man got on the boat, but when the tall man got on the boat he connected with the second short man whose picture I identified.
Q Now of this woman you saw, where did you first see her?
A In the trolley car.
Q Just the woman alone?
A That is all.
Q And the men went on their way. Did they go in an automobile?
A [A]fter they left the woman and put the woman on the car, they walked over to an automobile.
Q Now, have you ever seen this woman's picture [in a newspaper] before except here?
A Yes.
Q When is the first time you saw the picture of this lady in a newspaper?
A Oh, quite some time ago, I think
Q By what department were you employed in New York as a fingerprint expert?
A I was with the Magistrate's Court.
[Court recesses for the weekend]
Direct Examination by Mr. Reilly:
Q Mr. Sommer, what is your business?
A Why, my profession is a fingerprint expert.
Q Connected with whom?
A I was with the City in that capacity, but not now.
Q What do you do now for a living?
A I am with the Building & Supply Division of the Department of Public Welfare, City of New York.
Q On the evening of March 1st, 1932, where were you, in the early evening?
A In the early evening I was in Fairview, New Jersey.
Q Were you visiting there?
A Why, no, I was over there giving a fingerprinting instruction to William Ackerman, a policeman.
Q How did you travel, by car?
A No, by trolley car. I came down to the 42nd street ferry, Weehawken.
Q And what time did you arrive at the ferry?
A It was between 12 and 12:20.
Q Did you notice any people from the trolley that were afterwards on the ferry boat with you?
A There was two men.
Q Did you get a good look at them?
A A fairly good look at them, yes sir.
Q I show you a picture and ask you is that the man you saw on the trolley car?
A No, but I saw this man on the ferryboat.
Q And how near were you to him on the ferry?
A Why, I sat across the way from him.
Q How long were you riding on the ferryboat with this man under observation?
A Why, from the Jersey side to the New York side, about eight or ten minutes.
Q When the ferryboat landed, what did you see the man whose picture you identified here do?
A Why, him and another man assisted a lady on the trolley, with a baby; the woman had a baby.
Q And did you get on that trolley car?
A I did.
Q Did you get a good look at the woman holding the baby?
A What drew my attention to the woman, she was very nervous.
Q Did you get a good look at her?
A I did.
Q I show you Defendant's Exhibit 7 and ask if you recognize the woman in the trolley car with the baby?
A I would say that resembles the woman very strongly.
Q How was she dressed?
A She had a brown coat on with brown fur cuffs, and a brown collar. The coat was open. She had sort of a low cut waist and she had a sort of pearl necklace around her.
Q Now describe her actions in the trolley car with the baby.
A From the time she got on she appeared nervous, she always had one foot -- (witness indicates by holding his arms out) and as the car slowed up or stopped, she just appeared as though she was ready to jump out.
Q How was she holding the baby, what was the baby wrapped in?
A The baby was wrapped in a blanket. She would lift the baby up and the blanket slipped and I noticed the baby was dressed in a one-piece nighty.
Q And was the baby a brunette or a blond?
A The baby was a blond.
Q And how old?
A I would say about two years old.
Q When did you first learn of the kidnapping of the Lindbergh baby?
A Ten forty-five the next morning, I heard it over the radio.
Q Did you report the incident that you had seen the night before to the police?
A I did. On March 2nd, to Detective Mulaney of the 81st Precinct.
Q Did you report it to anyone else?
A I wrote a letter to the State Police, Trenton, New Jersey stating my experience on the ferry.
Q Did you ever get an answer?
A I did not. Nobody ever came to investigate.
Q How did you come to be a witness in this case?
A I wrote you a letter, about two weeks ago.
Q Before that you didn't even know me?
A I am not interested in you.
Q You are here in the interests of justice?
A I am.
Mr. Reilly: You may inquire.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Wilentz:
Q Did you communicate with the police after you spoke to this detective in New York on March 2nd, or was that the only incident?
A When I reported there they told me they had hundreds of clues.
Q That is right. Didn't they tell you that they had hundreds of people that came in and said they saw men with babies all over the country that night?
A Yes.
Q So they didn't put much stock in the story?
A Why, I don't know.
Q Well, they never came back, did they?
A That I can't say, because I moved after that.
Q Now, the short man you saw on the ferry, you didn't see on the trolley car, correct?
A Positive, that is correct.
Q Now the tall man that you say helped the woman on the trolley car, did you see him on the trolley car?
A He was on the trolley car.
[Mr. Wilentz pursues the witness' identification and travels, trying better to define where the tall and short men were at various times, going unsatisfactorily in circles.]
Mr. Reilly: I object to that. There is no contradiction. The witness has testified he came down on the Jersey side on a trolley car. He crossed over on a ferryboat and got on another trolley car in New York.
The Court: I will allow the question.
[More confusing dialogue between Mr. Wilentz and the witness concerning where and when Mr. Sommer encountered the two men.]
Q Now, am I mixing you up again?
A Why, positively, I want it explained and you told me to answer the question. I am trying to tell you when we got on the ferry the tall man got on the boat and I didn't see, I couldn't swear that the other short man got on the boat, but when the tall man got on the boat he connected with the second short man whose picture I identified.
Q Now of this woman you saw, where did you first see her?
A In the trolley car.
Q Just the woman alone?
A That is all.
Q And the men went on their way. Did they go in an automobile?
A [A]fter they left the woman and put the woman on the car, they walked over to an automobile.
Q Now, have you ever seen this woman's picture [in a newspaper] before except here?
A Yes.
Q When is the first time you saw the picture of this lady in a newspaper?
A Oh, quite some time ago, I think
Q By what department were you employed in New York as a fingerprint expert?
A I was with the Magistrate's Court.
[Court recesses for the weekend]