▲
Trial Excerpts

January 31, 1935

Flemington, New Jersey

Testimony of John Trendley for the Defense

JOHN M. TRENDLEY, sworn as a witness in behalf of the defendant

Direct Examination by Mr. Reilly:

Q  Mr. Trendley, where do you live?
A  East St. Louis, Illinois.
Q  And what is your profession?
A  Examining disputed documents for the last forty -- since 1895, forty years this May.
Q  And have you testified in court many times?
A  Somewhere around 387 or 388 times.

Mr. Reilly allows the state to interrogate now.

By Mr. Lanigan:

Q  Mr. Trendley, you are an imitator of handwriting, are you not?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  And you claim that you can speedily imitate a signature, do you not?
A  Not speedily, sometimes it takes time.
Q  Well, you claim to be able to produce spurious writings, that will deceive a witness?
A  I have done so.  In the Patrick Rice case, that is thirty years ago, I think I wrote nine signatures of old man Rice.
Q  Designed to do what?
A  To test the ability of the experts.
Q  To prove that the will was genuine?
A  Yes.
Q  [Quoting from a trial transcript in which Mr. Trendley had testified in 1932, the U.W. Thomason case in St. Louis]
"Well, as a matter of fact, you never anywhere in the whole 38 years of your experience have met a forger who can do as neat a job as you do, have you?"  To which you answered -- 'I don't know.'  Then the question came: 'You can do it better than anyone you ever met, can't you?'  To which you answered: 'That would be a kind of egotism on my part.'
"Q.  Do you know a better one?
"A  Yes, old man Becker.  Becker the forger.  He was the man that forged and raised a draft of $22,000 on a bank and the banking association wanted to pay him $5,000 a month to be good.
"Q  How long ago was that?
"A  I guess eighteen years ago.  He died like all of them, in the Penitentiary."
Q  Now, you have been frequently mistaken, haven't you, in the cases you have testified in?
A  Oh, I have, yes, I don't claim to being an authority over everybody.
Q  In the case of Edward Olmer, plaintiff, versus the Southern Manganese Steel Company, 1927, you gave two different opinions about the same handwriting in the same case, is that right?
A  Yes.

[Excerpts from the Olmer case continue, portraying the witness' mistake in differentiating between Ed Olmer's signature and that of his wife, allegedly signing time cards.]

[Excerpts from the Thomasson case present the witness as having changed his testimony during that trial as well:]

Q  In other words, with respect to the four of them which you had identified and testified to, with respect to each and every one you changed your testimony?
A  He passed them before I give them a curbstone opinion and he said he -- there were 1500 exhibits in that case.
Q  [Quoting from the Olmer case, referring to the Thomasson case:]
"Q.  Have you testified as an expert and given one side the opinion that a certain document was a forgery and gave the other side an opinion it was a genuine writing?
"A.  Yes, sir.  And I withdrew out of the case when I found the mistake.  I went down on a dark cloudy day in the probate courtroom to look at a will.  It was a day something like this, and I looked at it and made an examination and told the attorney what I thought of it.  Later on, I examined it again and I told him I would have to withdraw from the case, and I didn't appear for either side."
Q  Correct?
A  Yes.  The Probate Court in St. Louis is a very dark and gloomy place, and it was pouring rain and I didn't have much opportunity to look at it.
Q  So your explanation for that is it was a dark and gloomy day?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  All right.  Now let's get a case that wasn't on a dark and gloomy day.  [Quoting from the Olmer case again:]
"Did you not render to Mr. Young a written opinion in that case in which you told him for eight different reasons, set out in including pictorial effect, and all the other concomitants you have mentioned here, the signature on the release was not the signature of the man it purported to be?
"A  Yes, sir.
"Q  Did you not testify for Mr. Snyder that the signature which you had the day before announced as a forgery in the examination of Mr. Young was a true and correct genuine signature?  Did not Mr. Young thereupon file a motion for a new trial, in which he declared your testimony false and unworthy of belief?"
Mr. Lanigan:  In explanation, you made this answer:
"I was testifying for you in four courts, I got permission to leave the railroad for two hours to come over to your trial.  I had what we call a hot train to New Orleans, for the Pacific Coast, was to come into East St. Louis at 3:30 with 28 cars of bananas to be re-iced.  The Missouri-Pacific were holding a train to make an hourly run to ice the cars and get out of Illinois.  While testifying for you, the telephone rang, ... four o'clock had passed and my friend was on the train.  I didn't have my mind on the case."
Q  Is that correct?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Have you ever prepared any spurious writings whereby you have successfully misled Mr. John F. Tyrrell?
A  I don't know whether he was on the Patrick Rice case.  I may have.
Q  What did you do on the Patrick Rice case?
A  I wrote nine signatures of W.R. Rice.
Q  For the purpose of deceiving the people who would testify on the other side?
A  Testing their ability.
Q  The Court set the will aside, so you efforts came to naught?
A  Not there.
Q  You have testified here, being offered by the defense as an expert, that you make only cursory examinations and you give curbstone opinions?
A  I did in one case.
Q  And you change opinions in the middle of a case, correct?
A  One case out of 385.

Mr. Lanigan:  I object to the qualifications of the witness.

Mr. Reilly:  I submit his experience of 387 cases covering a period of 49 years -- and the Court will recall we didn't have the opportunity to send all over the world and examine into the records of the $150,000 case prepared by the State of New Jersey and the experts brought in here.  They brought men in here that we did not know five minutes before they took the stand they were going to be called.
     When we did get by wire instances of where Mr. Osborn corrected himself or was mistaken, and we asked him, he admitted it ... I say that a man who has testified in 387 cases, as Mr. Trendley has, and admits that in three or four cases he may have been mistaken, is honest in his opinion, but it doesn't destroy his value as an expert.
     This is not a science, this is the opinion of those who have devoted their lives to examining disputed writings and, while it is true he may have offered papers for the purpose of confusing the experts on the other side, that is no disrespect to him, nor does it lessen his ability as an expert.  I ask the Court to pass on his qualifications.

Mr. Lanigan:  I ask that the Court strike from the record the remarks of counsel, I think they are highly prejudicial about the State's $150,000 case and its experts.

Mr. Reilly:  I will strike out the $150,000 case.

The Court:  The jury will, of course, disregard that.

Mr. Reilly:  I will say a large amount and a large number of experts.  We come before the Court penniless.

Mr. Lanigan:  I will ask counsel to withdraw that, please.

Mr. Reilly:  I can't withdraw that which is a fact.

Mr. Lanigan:  I move to strike it.

The Court:  Well, I will strike that out because there is no evidence that it is penniless.  I now have this to say: It seems to me that the mere fact that this man admits having made a mistake and the mere fact that he gave curbstone opinions which he afterward corrected and testimony along that line, does not justify me in disqualifying him as an expert.  As to the value and weight that will be given to his testimony, that is a thing with which I am not presently concerned.
     You may proceed, Mr. Reilly.

Direct Examination (continued) by Mr. Reilly:

Q  Now we have it, Mr. Trendley, that in one instance you corrected your testimony yourself, and brought it to the attention of counsel and the Court yourself?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Did you, at the request of the counsel for the defense of this case some time in November, 1934, obtain photographic copies of different writings discussed in this case?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Did you attend the trial here and listen to the testimony of Mr. Osborn, and see the charts offered in evidence?
A  I did.
Q  Have you obtained and studied photographic copies of those charts and evidence?
A  I have.
Q  And you now have certain memoranda from which you desire to testify?
A  I have.

Mr. Reilly requests a recess until the following day in order to set up the exhibits and to rest his throat.