▲
Trial Excerpts

January 24, 1935

Flemington, New Jersey

Testimony of Arthur Koehler for the Prosecution

ARTHUR KOEHLER resumed the witness stand:

Direct examination (continued) by Mr. Wilentz:

[Mr. Wilentz introduces the automobile Mr. Hauptmann was driving when arrested, along with a photograph of it.]

Q  Now, Mr. Koehler, have you seen this automobile?
A  Yes.
Q  Did you take this ladder and attempt to fit it into that car?
A  I did.  When I took the three sections assembled and nested together, they fit in on top of the front and rear seats, and there were several inches to spare.

Mr. Wilentz:  Take the witness.

Cross examination by Mr. Pope:

Q  Mr. Koehler, when you fitted the ladder in the car, did you lay it on top of the seats?
A  Yes.
Q  With one end on top of the rear seat, how near did it come to the windshield?
A  About four or five inches.
Q  And lying in that position in the car, it could be readily seen by anyone looking in the car?
A  Yes.
Q  You have told us that you have testified in numerous cases, among them you mentioned one, a murder case.  What was the point involved in that case in your testimony?
A  A home made bomb was sent through the mails to a drainage Commissioner and when the Commissioner opened the package it exploded and his wife, who was standing nearby was killed.  The hollow cylinder portion of the bomb was wood.

[Mr. Pope establishes that Mr. Koehler has testified in less than a half-dozen trials, all the others being civil cases dealing with branding of lumber, tensile loading in load failures, or disputes as to correct delivery according to specifications.]

Q  Now, you have never undertaken to identify chisel marks or plane marks upon lumber in court before, have you?
A  In court?  No.
Q  This is the first time you have been called upon to testify to that?
A  Yes.
Q  Taking the structure of this ladder as a whole would you say that it was built by a mechanic or by an amateur or even less?  It is rather a poor job, isn't it?
A  Yes.
Q  Even the sawing of the notches is poorly done, isn't it?
A  Yes.
Q  From your knowledge of wood, would you think that a ladder constructed as this one, would hold the weight of a man of 180 pounds under those conditions?
A  Yes, I think it would.
Q  And could he go up and down readily without the ladder breaking?
A  He might.
Q  He might.
A carpenter building a ladder of that kind would generally space the rounds about a foot apart, wouldn't he?
A  That is the standard distance.
Q  These rounds on all the sections of this ladder are spaced a rather wide distance apart, are they not?
A  Unusually wide.

[An extended discussion of lumbers and locations of mills ensues.]

Q  Just one or two questions about the milling machine.  Did you determine at what speed the cutter head (with eight knives) was running on the planing mill in the Dorn mill in South Carolina?
A  Yes; 2700 revolutions per minute.
Q  That would mean that there were eight times 2700 cuts on the underside or the upper side of the board per minute, wouldn't it?
A  Yes.  Wait a minute.  Yes, that is right.
Q  About 22,000 cuts per minute?
A  Yes.
Q  Now the markings of a knife cut on the underside of a board going over a jointing machine or a planing machine depends whether or not there is any overlapping of the following knives, doesn't it, overlapping cuts?
A  Will you please repeat the question?
Q  I will put it this way to you.  If a board is run across a planer head moving with eight knives at 22,000 cuts per minute, if it is moved at a fairly rapid rate of speed, the result will be a perfectly smooth board, won't it?
A  No.  The faster it is run, the rougher the work it does.
Q  Isn't it the slow motion of a board across the planer that causes the ridges or ripples to show on the bottom of the board?
A  No.  The slow motion brings them closer together and makes them inconspicuous.

Mr. Pope:  Thank you very much, sir.

Re-direct examination by Mr. Wilentz:

Q  You said the ladder wasn't a good carpenter's job.  It was some sort -- are the tools a good carpenter's set of tools?
A  I wouldn't say so.
Q  Is the plane a good carpenter's plane?
A  No.
Q  Is the ladder a good carpenter's ladder?
A  No.

Re-cross examination by Mr. Pope:

Q  This type of ladder is a general plan and type of ladder used quite extensively in the South in the fruit industry, is it not?
A  Not to my knowledge.  I never saw a ladder like that before.
Q  Have you ever paid attention to the type of extension ladder used in the fruit picking areas of the South?
A  I didn't know they used sectional ladders.
Q  You never noticed that?
A  No.

Mr. Pope:  That is all.  Thank you.

Mr. Wilentz:  Mr. Koehler, that is all.  The State rests.