▲
Trial Excerpts

ca. January 11, 1935

Flemington, New Jersey

Testimony of Frank Kelly (recalled) for the Prosecution

FRANK A. KELLY, recalled for cross examination, testified as follows:

Cross examination by Mr. Reilly:

Q  I think when you left the stand you were to go and get some paraphernalia for taking fingerprints; is that right?
A  That is correct, yes.
Q  Now this piece of paper has been handled by counsel for the defense, two or three of them, and has been in the possession of the Clerk ever since.  Will you take this and show the jkury how you attempt to locate fingerprints?
A  Yes, sir.  Would you mind placing it there, Mr. Reilly?
Q  Sure; I will place it any place.
A  (The witness leaves the stand.)
Q  Couldn't you do it up there, Mr. Kelly, in front of the Judge and jury?
A  I believe so.  Just set it there.

(The witness proceeded with his demonstration.)

Q  Mr. Kelly, on the half that you brushed over have you found some prints?
A  On the half I have brushed over I have found some ridge formations from the finger, but I would say that they are prints of no value.
Q  All right.  Will you sift the others.
A  (The witness demonstrated.)
Q  You don't have to do any more, Mr. Kelly.  May I have the paper.
A  (Paper handed to counsel.)

[Mr. Reilly reiterates his incredulity at Mr. Kelly's inability to discover any usable fingerprints, thereby casting doubt on the dusting method.  Mr. Reilly then introduces the topic of a newer method, spraying with silver nitrate, to bring out the prints, even where dusting may have failed.  He introduces a board, similar to the wood of the ladder.)

Q  Well, look at this board I have offered for identification.  Are those finger prints?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Have you any silver nitrate here?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Will you take my fingerprint off this board in front of the jury, please?
A  If it is on there, I will try to.
Q  All right.  I am handing a board -- I am handing the board to you.  Now, will you please take it out with silver nitrate?
A  It has been found, Mr. Reilly, with the silver nitrate method of wood -
Q  I ask you to take it out, please, not how it has been found.

The Witness:  Will the Court allow me to explain?

The Court:  Yes.

A  It has been found that with the silver nitrate method on wood, better results are obtained after the prints are on there for a while.
Q  How long do you want my prints to stay on there?
A  Why, I could try your print on here with powder and possibly bring it out.
Q  I want it with silver nitrate.  Twenty-four hours, Forty-eight hours?
A  Oh, I should say overnight would be all right.
Q  All right.  How many days after the ladder was found did Mr. Hudson bring out with silver nitrate these fingerprints?
A  That would be 12 or 14 days afterward.
Q  Now suppose I put the board away.
A  By the edges, please.
Q  And don't touch it for two or three days and call you during the defense, will you bring it out then with silver nitrate?
A  I will try to bring out what is there.
Q  Now, the silver nitrate that was applied to the ladder -- were you ever asked to wash those stains off?
A  I was detailed to take the stains off, yes, sir.
Q  Did you take them off?
A  No, sir, I didn't.
Q  Were they taken off with a solution of bichloride of mercury?
A  I believe so.

Mr. Wilentz:  I expect to use that, Mr. Reilly, if you don't mind.  I just want you to know that.

Re-direct Examination by Mr. Wilentz:

Q  Tell me whether or not between the 1st of March and the 12th or 14th of March, a new process had not been discovered?
A  It had.
Q  What was the new process?
A  The silver nitrate process.
Q  So that when you first took the test of this ladder, the silver nitrate process, as I understand it, had not yet been discovered?
A  It was not known, no, sir.
Q  And between the time f discovery of the silver nitrate process and the time you took the test on this ladder, had there been many hands touching and handling that ladder?
A  Oh, yes, very many.
Q  As a matter of fact, a great number of police officers from all over the country and others had handled the ladder at that time?
A  Yes, sir, that is correct.
Q  If a man carried this ladder to the Lindbergh home and he carried it with gloves and he didn't take the gloves off, would he leave his fingerprints on it?
A  Absolutely not.
Q  If a man walked into the Lindbergh nursery and took that child and he had gloves on would he leave fingerprints?  So that it is only where a person does not use some instrument to hide his fingerprints that his fingerprints show: is that it?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  In addition to that, sir, do all impressions by fingers leave fingerprints?
A  Not of value, Mr. Wilentz.
Q  Well, when we talk about fingerprints, Mr. Reilly and myself, we mean fingerprints which can be traced or identified if the opportunity later presents itself.
A  Not all of them, no, sir.
Q  In other words, were I to take this paper, and, in the manner that I do now, and then attempt to stretch it like that (Mr. Wilentz takes piece of paper in his hands and jerks on both ends of it) would that have any effect on the prints?
A  Very much.
Q  If I touched it and just rubbed over it or handled it and moved my finger while I was doing it, would that leave a finger print or would it interfere with it?
A  It would interfere with it.

Mr. Wilentz:  Thank you, Trooper, that is all.

Re-cross examination by Mr. Reilly:

Q  Well now, if Mrs. Lindbergh or Betty Gow, in closing the window, pressed their hands down on top of the window and they had no gloves on, that would leave an impression of their hands and fingers, wouldn't it?
A  I have no information that they did.
Q  I am asking you if they did.
A  I don't know.
Q  I still appreciate you are a State Trooper, but I am asking you this question: if they closed the window with their hands, and had no gloves, it would leave an impression, wouldn't it.
A  It would leave a mark.
Q  And if the baby was kidnapped from that crib and taken down the back stairs, and nobody ever went near the window, the window would not show any fingerprints, would it?
A  No.

Mr. Reilly:  That is all.