▲
Trial Excerpts

January 8, 1935

Flemington, New Jersey

Testimony of Frank Kelly for the Prosecution

FRANK KELLY resumed the stand.

By Mr. Wilentz:

Q  Officer, you remember this nursery room, do you not?  I think that somewhere in the center of that room there was a table and chair?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  What have you to say as to whether or not the table was in direct line between the southeast window and the crib?
A  You could have walked a direct line from the window to the crib with no obstruction.
Q  As I understand yesterday, you stated in taking, attempting to take fingerprints in that baby's nursery, that you found none?
A  That is correct.
Q  You have been in court for several days, have you not?  You heard Miss Gow's and Mrs. Lindbergh's testimony that they had been in the room?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  You mean then that you found no fingerprints of anybody's?
A  I mean this --
Q  Just answer the question.
A  No, sir; nobody's at all.

Mr. Wilentz:  Mr. Reilly, take the witness.

Cross-examination by Mr. Reilly.

Q  Mr. Kelly, how much experience have you had in taking fingerprints?
A  Six years.
Q  Where did you study?
A  While I have been in the department.
Q  Did you ever study the Bertillon system?
A  No, sir, I did not.
Q  And, are you the, what is known as the expert of the Police Department, the State Police?
A  No, sir, I am not.
Q  Well, who takes the Bertillon measurements?
A  It is not used, it is obsolete.

Mr. Reilly:  I move the latter part be stricken out as a conclusion, "It is obsolete."

The Court:  Strike it out.

Q  The Bertillon system is a system of measuring by height, breadth and general dimensions, is that correct?
A  That is.
Q  Yes, it has been used for over 100 years in foreign countries and in America, hasn't it?
A  I couldn't say.
Q  Did you bring with you the paraphernalia this morning for taking fingerprints?
A  No, sir, I did not.

Mr. Reilly:  I understood from the table here, the prosecution would have them this morning.

Mr. Wilentz:  Well, if counsel wants them, I will certainly get them for him sometime today.

Q  Do you think you would be able to take fingerprints and give the jury an observation?
A  I would.
Q  Yes.  Now you want us to believe, do you, that you could find no fingerprints?
A  Of value.
Q  Of anybody you testified here, of anybody; is that correct?
A  That is correct.
Q  Yes.  Now you know, do you not, that there are no two finger prints in the world alike.  That we each have our own individual photographs on our finger prints?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Does that also apply to the feet?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  When you arrived at the house, who accompanied you to the nursery?
A  Colonel Lindbergh and Corporal Wolf.
Q  What was the first object you attempted to photograph or take fingerprints from?
A  The note.
Q  What did you do to this envelope to try and find fingerprints on it?
A  I at that time used a camel hair brush that is used by fingerprint operators and a black powder which is manufactured by Flaacke, standard fingerprint powder and the brush.
Q  First you take the powder and sift it on, don't you?
A  First I dip my brush into the bottle and sift the powder on and then brush over the surface of it.
Q  Is it not the proper way to take a fingerprint to sift the powder from the bottle over the paper and then blow it off and the powder remains where the fingerprints are?
A  No, sir, it is not.
Q  Do you not know that the brushing of your brush destroys the fingerprints?
A  I know in blowing it off you blow moisture on it and destroy the fingerprint.
Q  You can see me handle this paper?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  And counsel at the table are going to handle it now.  We are going to leave it right here with the clerk until you bring your apparatus.  That is what you did with the note, too, I assume, you brushed it with the brush?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  How long were you working on the note before you gave it up as hopeless as far as fingerprints went?
A  Possibly about half an hour.
Q  After the note, what was the next place?
A  I believe my next attempt was the window sill.
Q  When you arrived at the window, you found the window closed, is that correct?
A  That is correct.
Q  Did you find the latch open or closed?
A  Open.
Q  Did you do anything to the latch?
A  Processed it for fingerprints.
Q  Finally you got over to the crib, didn't you?
A  I did.
Q  Now did you hear Miss Gow's testify that she came into the crib, she leaned over the crib, she couldn't hear the baby breathing, and that she started to feel among the coverlets?  Did you hear her testify to that?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  And you want us to believe that you couldn't even get her fingerprints from that crib where she was looking for the baby?
A  If she leaned over.
Q  She touched the crib and she felt the crib, all around the crib.  You say there were no fingerprints of hers?
A  Exactly.
Q  And a fingerprint in your opinion will last how many days, if any?
A  It depends on atmospheric conditions, general conditions in the room or outside conditions.
Q  What atmospheric conditions in the nursery room would cause any fingerprint to disappear within two days?
A  I didn't say it was atmospheric conditions that caused it.
Q  What condition of any kind that you could imagine and know of could cause a fingerprint to disappear in that nursery room within two days?
A  General handling conditions.
Q  What authority did you ever study for fingerprinting?
A  I studied the Henry System.
Q  Who was Henry?
A  He is the man that invented the Henry System of classification of fingerprints and I studied that.
Q  And a man named Henry in England wrote the book?
A  As far as I recall.
Q  As far as you recall.  You have never studied any American system at all, have you?
A  That is the American system that has been used by police departments in the United States.
Q  Don't you know the system used in the United States is a system devised by ex-Inspector Forrot of the Police Department of New York?
A  No, I didn't.
Q  You didn't know that he was in charge of the N.Y.  Police Department on fingerprinting for twenty-five years?
A  I don't know what New York does.  I'm in Jersey.
Q  You didn't know he gave lectures to all the fingerprint men in the United States at least once a month?
A  I never heard tell of the man.
Q  Now, what has been your experience in preserving foot-prints?
A  Will you be more definite on that, please?
Q  Yes.  Assuming that a man stepped into a muddy hole and left behind him a foot-print as has been photographed here.  Outside of photography how would you preserve the foot-print?
A  If I was the only investigator, I would preserve it by measuring it, making a mould of it.
Q  Who measured it, as far as you know?
A  I believe Detective DeGaetano did.
Q  Before you arrived?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Did you ask him?
A  No, sir.
Q  Did you take a mould?
A  No, sir.
Q  Now, as to the ladder, do you know it has been reported that one man took over 800 fingerprints from this ladder?

Mr. Wilentz:  I object to the question, if your Honor please.  I think -

Mr. Reilly:  All right, I am ahead of myself.  I will withdraw it.

Q  Did you get any fingerprints from the ladder?
A  No, sir, I did not.
Q  How soon after you were finished with the ladder was it examined by Government men?
A  Do you mean a police conference, Mr. Reilly?
Q  No, I will put it this way: I don't want to anything to confuse you.  The ladder was brought into the Lindbergh home in two sections, correct?  They were loosely joined; is that correct?
A  Correct.
Q  And where was it put when it was brought in?
A  I received the ladder in the hallway.  I worked on it right there in the hall.
Q  What condition was the ladder in?  Was it dry or wet?
A  It was dry.
Q  Wasn't it covered with frost?
A  No, sir.
Q  Cold night, wasn't it?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  There wasn't any moisture on it at all?
A  No, sir.

[Mr. Reilly then brings in the existence of another ladder, an extension ladder belonging to the Lindberghs, kept in the garage.]

Q  The [extension] ladder was brought in to you or did you go up to the garage?
A  I went to the garage.
Q  When?
A  As soon as I asked about it.
Q  Well, when -- I don't know when that was, that day, or the next day, or when?
A  That day.
Q  That day.  I suppose you stayed right on the job, did you, right through until about noon the next day: is that right?
A  Oh, no.  I didn't leave the premises; I was right there.
Q  Until how long?
A  Until June.
Q  Couple of days -- You lived right on the premises, did you?
A  Yes, I did.
Q  Now, you knew, did you not, that you were there for the purpose of preserving evidence for any trial that might ever come up: is that correct?
A  Correct.

Mr. Reilly:  With the understanding that this witness is to be recalled when he comes back with his paraphernalia, I am through for the present.

Re-direct examination by Mr. Wilentz:

Q  Just one question, Mr. Reilly: do you remember about what hour it was that you processed this ladder?
A  Between one and one-thirty....