▲
Trial Excerpts

January 7, 1935

Flemington, New Jersey

Testimony of Frank Kelly for the Prosecution

FRANK A. KELLY, sworn in as a witness on behalf of the State:

Direct examination by Mr. Wilentz:

Q  Young man, you are connected with the State Police of New Jersey, are you not?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  You have been connected with the State Police how long?
A  It will be eight years the 15th of this coming August.
Q  And as a result of some injury that you received, then you went to this work that you are doing now: isn't it?
A  Identification work, yes, sir.
Q  And in that connection you take photographs?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Fingerprints and things of that kind?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  All forms of identification?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  You have attempted to school yourself and learn as much as you could about it: is that so?  And you have been doing that work for the State Police for how many years?
A  About six years.
Q  About six years.  And in that capacity did you come to the Lindbergh home on the night to March 1st, 1932?
A  On the morning of March 2nd.
Q  About what time?
A  Five minutes after twelve.
Q  And when you got there, where did you go and what did you do, sir?
A  Upon my arrival I was met at the front entrance of the Lindbergh home by Corporal Wolfe, and Colonel Lindbergh, who directed me to the nursery on the second floor of the home.
Q  When you got to the nursery did you see a note there?
A  Yes, sir; I did.
Q  And did you take that note and test it for fingerprint?
A  Yes, sir; I did.
Q  And this envelope, S-17, and the note, S-18, both of which bear your initials on them somewhere, are those the papers that you tested that night?
A  They are.
Q  Was the note in the envelope?
A  It was.
Q  Did you take it out?
A  I did.
Q  And did you find any fingerprints there on?
A  I did not.
Q  Did you use such appliances as to you or such methods as were known to you that night to the best of your ability, try to find fingerprints?
A  I did.

Mr. Pope:  We object to that question; we are entitled to know what methods he used; then we will determine whether they are the best methods or not.

Mr. Wilentz:  Who is going to determine that?

The Court:  Well, you have the full right of cross examination in respect to that.  I apprehend that the Attorney General thinks that he has qualified this officer as a fingerprint expert.  Do you deny that, Mr. Pope?

Mr. Reilly:  I think we will handle it under cross examination.

The Court:  Very well.

Q  Those two things just referred to, you tested so far as those fingerprints are concerned?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  What else did you do, sir?
A  I made a general observation of the nursery, the conditions therein, noticed the crib and processed the rest of the room for fingerprints, noticed the dirt marks described by Trooper Wolfe on the floor and on the leather bag directly under the window.  My duties consisted of trying to take fingerprints on various parts of the articles in the nursery, photographs on the interior of the same and processing the ladder that was brought in by Trooper Bornmann for prints.
Q  With reference to your efforts in the room, did you attempt to get any fingerprint evidence in the room aside from the note?
A  Yes, sir; I did.
Q  What did you process besides the note and the envelope?
A  I processed the window sill, the window, inside and out, the crib, the screen, the light in back of the screen, the French windows, the window on the north side of the nursery, that is the north window on the east side of the nursery, the bureau drawers, a little chair that was at the foot of the crib, everything in the room that it was possible to obtain a fingerprint from.
Q  Did you find any fingerprints upon those articles?
A  No, sir; I did not.
Q  Now, what else then did you do later?
A  I later was called down into the hall by Bornmann, who had brought that ladder in to me.
Q  When you got down to the hall, did Bornmann give you a ladder?
A  He gave me two sections of a ladder.  And later he brought in another section of the ladder and a chisel.
Q  And was the dowel pin in there with it?
A  It was.
Q  The two that he brought in together, were they somewhat connected, the two sections of the ladder?
A  Somewhat connected and somewhat disconnected.
Q  I see.  Just a minute.  I show you S-32 and ask you whether that is the ladder, the three sections, that Bornmann gave you that night?
A  May I examine that, please?
Q  You certainly may.
A  (The witness steps from the witness stand and examines the ladder) Yes, sir, it is.
Q  How about this dowel pin?
A  That dowel pin was in the ladder.
Q  How about the other dowel pin?
A  The other dowel pin was outside in the yard.
Q  Outside in the yard so that one dowel pin was in the ladder and the other was outside.  Now, except for that is there anything about that section that is different than the morning of March 2nd, 1932, when it was given to you by the police officer that you referred to a minute ago?
A  No, sir; there was not.
Q  All right, sir.  Then you came down, I take it, you processed this ladder?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  And found no fingerprints on it?
A  I did not.
Q  What did you do then?
A  I returned to the nursery to continue my investigation there.  I noticed during this investigation that there was a leather case on top of a wooden chest directly under this window, the southeast window.  There was a marking of dirt -
Q  Yes.
A  On, facing the leather case on the lefthand side, apparently a slide -

Mr. Reilly:  I object to the apparently.

The Witness:  It was my opinion at that time --

Mr. Reilly:  I object to your opinion.

The Court:  Well, just tell us what you found.

The Witness:  This dirt mark on the leather case.  Directly under that on the floor there was another dirt mark.

By Mr. Wilentz:

Q  Just wait a minute.  We will identify the leather case which you are talking about, which I think has already been done.  I show you Exhibit S-11.  You notice a leather case there right near the southeast window?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  Is that the leather case you are referring to?
A  It is.
Q  Now, on what part of the leather case was the dirt smudged?
A  Facing the leather case it was on the lefthand corner.  Nearest to the crib.
Q  Then what did you do?  What else did you see, rather?
A  I noticed on the floor directly under that there was a dirt smudge.  And in the middle of the floor, going in a direction to the crib from the window there was another dirt marking on the floor.
Q  Did you test those?  Did you make any test with reference to them of any kind at all?
A  Other than noticing the color of the dirt in the yard and the color on the floor, that was the only test that I made.
Q  Now, then, what did you do, sir?
A  I continued my investigation the following morning, as soon as it got light outside and made photographs of outside conditions.
Q  Now, did you -- I notice that S-36 is the picture of a footprint.  Did you do anything about encasing it?
A  No, sir, I did not.
Q  Did you do anything about preserving it?
A  It was preserved when it was pointed out to me.  Lieutenant Lang was in custody of it to see that nobody destroyed it or tampered with it in any way.
Q  I see, but you did nothing of your own account to test it, measure it, preserve it, encase it, or anything else?
A  No, sir.
Q  With reference to the dowel pin attached to one of the sections -- Now, was the ladder which Lieutenant Bornmann gave to you on the premises assembled together in three sections?
A  No, sir; it was not.
Q  I mean eventually was it put together?
A  Oh, yes.
Q  Was it put together in your presence, the very ladder that was there?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  And was it placed against the house?
A  It was.
Q  What did you observe when you did that?
A  I observed that at the top section, that is, the top of the second section, where the ladder rested against the wall of the house, that there were markings, that is the width of the ladder about an inch and a half to two inches above that top section of the second ladder.
Q  I don't understand about that inch and a half that you were just talking about.
A  Placing the ladder -
Q  First, when you placed the ladder did you place the ladder in the indentation shown near the boardwalk in Exhibit S-37?
A  I did.
Q  That is where you rested the ladder?
A  Exactly.
Q  All right.  Now, were the two sections of the ladder and were the foot of the ladder there in those two holes -- By the way, did they fit?
A  Exactly.
Q  All right, sir.  Then since it did fit you put it against the house at that point?
A  I did.

Mr. Reilly:  Again you are leading.  I am sorry, but my brothers of the Bar are so nervous from your leading I must object.Mr. Wilentz: I think maybe you are right, but sometimes in our enthusiasm -- we forget.

Q  Is this the picture of the ladder as you placed it with the two pieces of wood in those holes shown in S-37?
A  It is.
Q  Does it correctly portray the ladder placed against the east side of the house, the bottom part of the ladder in the indentations shown in S-33?
A  It does.

Mr. Wilentz:  I offer it in evidence.

Mr. Reilly:  We object to it.

The Court:  Object?

Mr. Reilly:  We do.

The Court:  On what grounds?

Mr. Reilly:  On the ground that it does not conform to the testimony heretofore given.  It shows a window of a third floor, apparently the nursery, with the shutters off, window open, the general condition not as heretofore testified to.

The Court:  Well, it purports to be a photograph of an experiment.  Do you put your objection upon that ground?

Mr. Reilly:  Yes, sir.  Also upon the ground that it portrays and might portray and convey to the jury a wrong impression.  It does not conform to the evidence as given heretofore, the physical condition of the outside of that house.

Mr. Wilentz:  If your Honor please, it is offered for the purpose of illustration.  It is intended to be helpful to the Court and to the jury, and there is nothing about that except the open windows -- It is the same ladder, it is the same house -- and there is nothing about that picture that the Court cannot instruct the jury about if it so happens that it should escape their memory, the fact that the windows we claim were closed at the time.  But I think that it will be helpful and I don't see why there should be objection if it is going to be helpful.

Mr. Reilly:  Whether it is helpful or not we are relying upon the strict rules of evidence.  I think we are perfectly within our rights.

The Court:  I suppose the true rule is that either side has a right to make an experiment under substantially the conditions which are of interest to the case and to prove the result of that experiment.  That is the rule; but this proposition seems to be rather an extension of the rule and I would think that at the moment I ought to sustain this objection.

Mr. Wilentz:  Well, if your Honor pleases, before there is anything like that, let me state very respectfully, that I cannot see how it is anything but a simple experiment and not an extension of the rule; because we have not only the same house, but we have not brought a strange ladder on the theory that someone may have brought one to fit; we have the very same ladder, the very indentations there, the same house, everything identical, except for the physical fact that a window may have been closed or opened, which is a minor matter after all ...  we have certainly used only those things that were there, without a foreign object.

Mr. Reilly:  If I may look at the photograph, there is no evidence in this case, either direct or, to my mind, circumstantial to this case, that the child was passed out that window and down any ladder or down this ladder, and I contend that this is merely an experiment with a ladder found seventy-five feet away, brought to the house and placed in some holes; the shutters are taken off the house, off the window; the window is left open, to convey to this jury an improper idea ...  that it would be possible to go up the ladder against the shutters, open the shutters with the ladder leaning against them, come down, then with your window open go up the ladder again without moving the ladder, go in a window, take the child out and come down the ladder again, and still shut the shutters after you, and leave a note, your visiting card, on the radiator.

Mr. Wilentz:  If your Honor please, may I suggest to my delightful adversary's summation that this ladder when placed in the manner that we are attempting to show it with the two sections, and I don't want my adversary to get impatient, because we will show it, placed roughly -

Mr. Reilly:  I am not getting impatient.

Mr. Wilentz:  - placed right up against that building, is placed in such a way that it never approaches the shutters and the shutters have got nothing to do with it.  Underneath the window it falls, when you place the ladder in the two holes, the shutters are no obstruction at all, having nothing to do with this case.  That is the main reason I think this experiment is necessary, an illustration.  Let him take that ladder and take that view and situation as an experiment and let him explain it away.

Mr. Reilly:  Now it seems to be the contention of the General that he brings in a ladder of three sections of which only two were used.

Mr. Wilentz:  That's right; we will prove that.

Mr. Reilly:  That is entirely different from his opening.  "I will bring in a ladder of three sections" up which you say this kidnapper went.  Now you are trying to hedge and say he went up two.

Mr. Wilentz:  No.  You say we are hedging.  I want to show you that there is no hedging, the very ladder and we will show that that was used in the kidnapping and the murder.

The Court:  Well, I am inclined to think at this moment that the State should be confined to proof by the witnesses who can speak concerning what sort of an experiment was made, and he may state the result of that experiment subject to the Court's ruling, and after all that is done, then if there seems to be any necessity for the picture of this experiment, then we will rule on the picture.

Mr. Wilentz:  Thank you, sir and I withdraw the offer.

Q  And, Kelley, tell us just exactly what you did in this experiment?
A  In this experiment I placed the ladder, with two sections, with the lower part resting in these two marks that were found.  The bottom section was placed in those marks and the top part of the ladder rested against the house.  Upon examination I found that where the top section of the ladder rested against the house, that directly over the top two rungs, there were two marks about an inch and a half to two and half inches long that could in my opinion be cause –

Mr. Reilly:  I object to your opinion.

Q  Not in your opinion, what did they do with them right with the ladder?
A  They were right with the ladder; yes, sir.
Q  What kind of marks were they?
A  Ladder marks.

Mr. Reilly:  I move to strike that out as calling for a conclusion, unless the ladder in his experiment made the marks.

The Court:  I decline to strike it out.

Q  And now, did you also make an experiment with three sections?
A  Yes, sir.
Q  And what did you find when the ladder with three sections was placed against the house?
A  It went up above the window.
Q  All right sir; now, when you got up this second -- with the ladder, the two sections, did you take a look at the shutter?
A  Yes, I did.
Q  What kind of material was on the side of this house?
A  Stone.
Q  What color was the stone?
A  White.  I would say whitewash, it was painted with a whitewash or white paint.
Q  Were the marks that you speak of, that you saw when you placed the two sections against the house, the marks that you referred to before as ladder marks, were they plain?
A  Very.  The gray of the stone showed through just a bit.
Q  Now, with reference to that particular top section of ladder, did you notice whether there were any marks on the top of the ladder?
A  When the ladder was brought in to me by Bornmann, I noticed on the top inside section of No. 2 that rested against the top that we are referring to now there were two white marks.
Q  What sort of white marks were they?
A  I would say paint.

[Mr. Reilly objects, "merely a conclusion."  The Court declines to strike.]

Mr. Wilentz:  Now, if your Honor please, it is just about the closing hour and it is still quite stuffy here.  Would your Honor mind if we steal these two minutes and adjourn at this time before we go into another subject?

[The Court recesses for the day.]